The British Orthodox Church - Fellowship Forum
Divorce and remarriage in Egypt - Printable Version

+- The British Orthodox Church - Fellowship Forum (
+-- Forum: News & Events (
+--- Forum: News and Events (
+--- Thread: Divorce and remarriage in Egypt (/showthread.php?tid=416)

Divorce and remarriage in Egypt - Fr Gregory - 31-05-2010

A recent decision by an Egyptian (civil) court will pose problems for the Coptic Orthodox canonical courts. The following is the best (of many) reports on the matter.

Fr Gregory

Egypt court says Copts can remarry


Published: May 30, 2010 23:38 Updated: May 30, 2010 23:38

CAIRO: An Egyptian court has ruled that two Coptic men have the right to remarry, contradicting the church's position and undermining its efforts to maintain its authority over the Christian community in Muslim-majority Egypt.

Saturday's administrative court decision was prompted by a rare intervention by Pope Shenouda, leader of Egypt's Copts, who launched an appeal by the church against another court ruling made in March 2008 that had approved the request by the two divorcees to remarry.
The ruling challenges the church's efforts to hold sway over its flock and guard Coptic values in Egypt. Christians, mostly Copts, are about 10 percent of Egypt's 78 million people.

"This verdict is not binding on the church," said Coptic lawyer Mamdouh Ramzi, referring to Saturday's court ruling.

While it is accepted practice in the Muslim community, divorce and remarriage is only allowed in the Coptic tradition in certain cases, such as where adultery is involved, he said.

The church did not issue a statement on the verdict, but Ramzi said the pope's secretary had said in response that Copts could not act against the teachings of their holy book.

"We do not object to court rulings but the church has principles that no one can break, not even Pope Shenouda," said Ramzi, who has acted in cases to defend the church's position in the past. He said many Copts could be upset by the decision.

The two men had raised the court challenge against the church's decision to block their remarriage. The administrative court ruling is based on an assessment of the constitution.

Egyptian rights lawyer Hossam Bahgat said Saturday's verdict was "the first of its kind" and said it showed the need for civil marriages to be recognized in Egypt, where religious ceremonies are the only ones now accepted.

Analysts said the case highlighted tensions between the church and the authorities. The church publicly supports the government of President Hosni Mubarak but sometimes complains that grievances are not properly addressed.

Relations between Egypt's Copts and Muslim communities are generally calm, but can sometimes erupt into violence over issues such as land and inter-faith marriages or relationships.

"The case reflects tension between the church and the state," said Nabil Abdel Fattah, an Egyptian analyst at the Al-Ahram Center for Political and Strategic Studies.

"It shows Pope Shenouda's ... desire to impose his powers, instead of the state's, over the Christian community," he said.

Under Egypt's personal laws, marriage and divorce proceedings are based on the couple's religion. But in any marriage between a Muslim and non-Muslim, Islamic law prevails.

In another case in 2002, a court ruled that a Coptic woman, the well-known Egyptian actress Hala Sidki, could divorce her Coptic husband. But she only won her case after years spent in in court and after the church relented and backed her divorce.

<!-- m --><a class="postlink" href=""></a><!-- m -->

divorec and remarriage in coptic church - kirk yacoub - 01-06-2010

This seems just another stage in the Egyptian state's campaign against the Coptic Church. If the two Coptic men in question are granted a divorce by a civil court and re-marry, then obviously that marriage will not be recognized by the Church, leading to their inability to receive the Holy Sacraments. This would, perhaps, lead to further decisions by the court to demand that the Church commune them...
Be prepared for a further onslaught against the Church. Let us now prepare an internatinal campaign to make the Egyptian state think twice.

Kirk Yacoub

- John Charmley - 01-06-2010

Dear Kirk,

Whilst wholly sympathetic, I somehow cannot see the West rallying to a defence of the Coptic position.